Siesta Key Homes with Lake Front Water Frontage

Siesta Key Homes with Lake Front Water Frontage

Welcome to Siesta Key, Florida—a picturesque island paradise nestled in Sarasota County, where the sun-drenched beaches and azure waters create a serene backdrop for your dream home. Renowned for its powdery white sands and vibrant sunsets, Siesta Key is not just a destination; it’s a lifestyle. With a charming blend of laid-back coastal living and upscale amenities, this idyllic locale offers an array of activities, from kayaking in tranquil waters to indulging in exquisite dining experiences.

One of the most enchanting features of Siesta Key is its stunning lakefront properties. Picture waking up each morning to the gentle sounds of nature, with the shimmering waters just steps from your door. Homes with lakefront and waterfront access here are more than just residences; they are gateways to a lifestyle of relaxation and recreation. Imagine sipping your morning coffee on a private dock, watching the sunrise reflect on the water, or hosting sunset gatherings with friends and family, all while surrounded by the lush, tropical landscape.

Siesta Key boasts a vibrant community rich in culture, art, and outdoor adventures. Explore the local boutiques, savor fresh seafood at waterfront restaurants, or take a leisurely stroll along the beach. For those seeking a tranquil retreat with the convenience of urban amenities, Siesta Key’s lakefront homes offer the perfect blend of comfort and luxury. Come discover the magic of Siesta Key, where your dream home awaits amidst the beauty of Florida’s Gulf Coast.

Newest Siesta Key Homes with Lake Front Water Frontage

7200 Melaleuca Way, Sarasota
$3,100,000
3 Beds ⋅ 5 Baths ⋅ Sanderling Club SubDv. ⋅ 34242 Zip Code
Discover coastal living at 7200 Melaleuca Way, a custom waterfront home in the private Sanderling Club on Siesta Key, Florida. Built in 2018 on approximately three-quarters of an acre, this residence combines coastal architecture, detailed craftsmanship, and access to the natural beauty of Heron Lagoon. Offering approximately 3,587 square feet of living space, the home includes three bedrooms, four full bathrooms, and one half bath. Soaring ceilings, custom millwork, and generously proportioned rooms define the interiors. Concrete block construction and impact-rated windows and doors complement the home’s design with practical features that distinguish it within Siesta Key’s housing market. Designed for entertaining and everyday comfort, the living spaces connect to an outdoor retreat with a swimming pool, spa, and grounds that provide room to relax in privacy. A private dock on Heron Lagoon offers a setting for kayaking, paddleboarding, and observing island wildlife. The three-car garage accommodates vehicles, recreational equipment, and storage. Residents of Sanderling Club enjoy a private Gulf-front beach, clubhouse, and tennis facilities, along with access to community boat slips for owners, subject to availability and a waitlist. Nearby, Siesta Key Village offers restaurants, boutiques, and live music that complement the island lifestyle. Spend the day paddleboarding on Heron Lagoon, strolling Siesta Key’s celebrated white-sand beaches, or gathering with friends for dinner in the Village. At 7200 Melaleuca Way, architectural craftsmanship and a private waterfront setting come together in one of Siesta Key, Florida’s most distinctive coastal communities.

7200 Melaleuca Way, Sarasota
8328 Midnight Pass Road, Sarasota
$772,000
Siesta SubDv. ⋅ 34242 Zip Code
Your Siesta Key Waterfront Dream Awaits! Set along the scenic shores of Heron Lagoon, this approximately quarter-acre homesite on Midnight Pass Road offers an exceptional opportunity to create your dream island retreat. Enjoy expansive water views and a peaceful, private setting surrounded by the natural beauty of Florida’s Gulf Coast. Imagine leisurely days spent kayaking or paddleboarding on the lagoon, taking in the tranquil scenery, and embracing the relaxed rhythm of waterfront living. Perfectly balancing seclusion and convenience, this special property places you just a short drive from Turtle Beach and its beautiful sandy shoreline. Fabulous local restaurants and a marina are approximately half a mile to the south, while the vibrant Stickney Point area is only about a mile away, offering additional dining, shopping, and convenient mainland access. Whether you envision a stunning coastal residence or a peaceful island getaway, this is your chance to bring your vision to life in one of Sarasota’s most desirable coastal destinations. From beautiful water views and natural surroundings to nearby beaches, boating, and dining, this enchanting homesite offers the opportunity to experience the very best of the Siesta Key lifestyle. Bring your dreams and make this special waterfront setting your own!

8328 Midnight Pass Road, Sarasota
120 Whispering Sands Drive Unit V20, Sarasota
$725,000
3 Beds ⋅ 3 Baths ⋅ Whispering Sands SubDv. ⋅ 34242 Zip Code
RARELY AVAILABLE & EXQUISITELY REMODELED! Discover an exceptional 3 bedroom/3 bath freestanding villa with 2-car garage in Whispering Sands, Siesta Key’s coveted resort style GULF FRONT community on 800’ of private beach! Completely gutted and reimagined in 2016, this remarkable residence showcases creative design, quality finishes, and meticulous attention to detail throughout. An impressive 1,640 square feet of interior living space unfolds beneath soaring vaulted ceilings, with an open concept layout designed for effortless living and entertaining. The expansive 16' x 22' living room is delightfully complemented by sophisticated indirect LED illumination. Beautiful ceramic plank flooring flows throughout. The spacious entertainer’s kitchen combines style and function with granite countertops, a generous breakfast bar, soft close cabinetry & pullout drawers, LG and Bosch stainless appliances, and recessed and pendant lighting. The spacious primary suite offers two closets – a custom walk-in and a separate built-in. The third bedroom could also easily function as a home office, featuring a built-in desk, shelving, and custom closet. All three beautifully remodeled bathrooms feature granite counters, soft close cabinetry, tiled glass-enclosed walk-in showers, recessed lighting, and/or skylights. Two out of three bathrooms are ensuite — a rare advantage. All 2016 hurricane impact windows and sliders. Extend your entertaining outdoors into the private fenced brick paver patio, complete with a gas grill, with propane tank and gas hookup. The epoxy finished 2-car garage includes a full size LG washer and dryer, utility sink, workbench and shelving – and plenty of space for your bikes and beach essentials. Enjoy the Whispering Sands lifestyle. Just around the corner from famous Siesta Key Village, this 55+ Gulf front community includes 800’ of private quartz sand beach, two heated pools, clubhouse (currently undergoing complete remodeling), beachside Tiki Hut, shuffleboard, and canoe/kayak storage. Don’t miss this distinctive villa offering exceptional space, privacy, and effortless coastal living!

120 Whispering Sands Drive Unit V20, Sarasota
4805 Ocean Boulevard, Sarasota
$1,199,000
Twitchell Ralph S Siesta Key SubDv. ⋅ 34242 Zip Code
LOCATION, LIFESTYLE, AND EXCEPTIONAL POTENTIAL! Discover an opportunity to create your dream home on the highly desirable north end of Siesta Key. Situated along Ocean Boulevard, this approximately 0.36-acre corner parcel offers an exceptional setting for a custom coastal residence in one of Sarasota's most sought-after island communities. With the previous residence demolished, the property presents a fresh canvas to bring your architectural vision to life. Imagine a thoughtfully designed island retreat with expansive indoor-outdoor living spaces, a private pool, lush tropical landscaping, and the comforts of modern coastal living, subject to applicable building requirements and approvals. Here, the true value lies in the land, location, and lifestyle. Enjoy convenient proximity to the vibrant Siesta Key Village, known for its eclectic collection of restaurants, charming boutiques, outdoor cafés, nightlife, and entertainment. The world-renowned white quartz sand beaches of Siesta Key are also nearby, with public Beach Access #2 located near Avenida Messina and Beach Road. Spend your days enjoying the Gulf Coast, exploring the Village, or simply embracing the relaxed elegance of island living. Whether you envision a private coastal sanctuary or your next custom home project, this property offers a compelling opportunity to create something extraordinary in an established Siesta Key location. Bring your vision and discover the possibilities at 4805 Ocean Boulevard. Buyer to independently verify lot dimensions, boundaries, setbacks, easements, flood elevation requirements, utilities, and development feasibility. Property is being sold AS IS, WHERE IS. Sale is subject to court approval due to guardianship.

4805 Ocean Boulevard, Sarasota
6287 Midnight Pass Road Unit 103, Sarasota
$619,000
2 Beds ⋅ 2 Baths ⋅ Excelsior Beach To Bay SubDv. ⋅ 34242 Zip Code
Priced to sell. Welcome to your sunny slice of paradise on Siesta Key. This bright and inviting south-facing condominium offers a great opportunity to enjoy island living just near the world-famous white quartz sand of Siesta Beach. This generously sized two-bedroom, two-bath residence has been well maintained by its original owner and occasionally occupied. The desirable southern exposure fills the condominium with natural light throughout the day, creating an open and welcoming atmosphere. The interior has been recently painted, giving the home a fresh, clean look, ready for your personal touches. The unit includes several updates, including a newer stack washer and dryer, newer air-conditioning system, plus energy-efficient LED lighting. The spacious layout provides comfortable living and dining areas along with a generously sized main bedroom en suite, making it ideal for year-round living, seasonal use or taking advantage of the Excelsior on-site rental program with a two-week rental minimum. Convenience is key with under-building assigned parking as well as a private storage closet for beach chairs, umbrellas and other beach essentials. This bay-to-beach complex offers an easy distance across the street to the powdery sand and turquoise Gulf waters of internationally recognized Siesta Key Beach. Residents and renters enjoy an impressive array of resort-style amenities. The property features tennis and pickleball courts, beautifully maintained grounds, bayside grilling areas, and bayside and Gulf-side swimming pools. Whether you prefer relaxing by the water, enjoying sunset walks along the beach or staying active with outdoor recreation, this community offers something for everyone. With its prime location, bright southern exposure and access to outstanding amenities, this Siesta Key condominium presents a wonderful opportunity to own a piece of Florida’s sought-after coastal lifestyle.

6287 Midnight Pass Road Unit 103, Sarasota
8212 Midnight Pass Rd Road Unit 1-10, Sarasota
$4,500,000
34242 Zip Code
Siesta Key Bungalows is a cozy island offering 10 one-bedroom bungalows, some over looking the tranquil pristine blue waters of Heron Lagoon, and others overlook the lush tropical courtyard of Siesta Key Bungalows. The Bungalows sit less than a mile away from Siesta Key's beaches and boast free kayaking and canoeing on Heron Lagoon as well as a sparkling, heated pool and affordable rates year round. Siesta Key Bungalows are located near all 3 beaches on Siesta Key. You will be able to view all the beauty Siesta Key has to offer. Siesta Key offers a free trolley that connects the entire island including Siesta Key Bungalows. Gross income in past years prior to the hurricane was just over $500,000.00. Net operating income was just over $200,000.00 for the year.

8212 Midnight Pass Rd Road Unit 1-10, Sarasota
9397 Midnight Pass Road Unit 506, Sarasota
$665,000
2 Beds ⋅ 2 Baths ⋅ Pointe On Midnight Pass SubDv. ⋅ 34242 Zip Code
LIVE WHERE THE GULF MEETS THE BAY. Discover an extraordinary island lifestyle at The Pointe on Midnight Pass, a private, gated, waterfront community at the southernmost tip of Siesta Key, uniquely positioned at the convergence of The Gulf of America, Little Sarasota Bay, and Blind Pass Lagoon. This beautifully renovated 2-bedroom, 2-bath residence captures the rare magic of both sides of the island—wake to spectacular sunrises over Little Sarasota Bay and the Jim Neville Nature Preserve, then watch the sky transform at sunset over The Gulf. Thoughtfully updated, the residence features elegant tray ceilings and recessed lighting, solid-wood cabinetry, granite countertops, stainless-steel appliances, breakfast bar and pantry, contemporary baths with floor-to-ceiling tile, ceramic tile flooring throughout, sleek white interior doors, and sun-control shades on the lanai. A spacious lanai extends the living space outdoors, creating the perfect setting for morning coffee, sunset cocktails, or watching dolphins, manatees, seabirds and boats move through the surrounding waters. A private utility room houses the washer and dryer, while ground-level storage provides coveted space for beach, boating and golf gear. And then there is The Pointe—more than five acres of waterfront living, surrounded by water on three sides and embraced by an extensive seawall, with pathways winding throughout lush, mature tropical vegetation. Enjoy a heated pool and spa, lighted tennis and pickleball courts, fitness center, sauna, clubhouse, private island pavilion with grills, kayak and canoe storage and launches, fishing areas, boat docks, and on-site management—with a vibrant social calendar during season that brings neighbors together and makes it easy to connect, participate, or simply enjoy the island lifestyle at your own pace. The newly reopened Midnight Pass adds another extraordinary dimension, reconnecting the Gulf and Intracoastal waters and enhancing the boating, fishing and wildlife experience right outside your door. Walk or bike to Turtle Beach, enjoy nearby restaurants, or take the trolley to explore more of Siesta Key. This is not simply a condominium—it is the rare opportunity to own a front-row seat to the natural beauty, wildlife and ever-changing waters of southern Siesta Key.

9397 Midnight Pass Road Unit 506, Sarasota
8302 Midnight Pass Road, Sarasota
$1,400,000
4 Beds ⋅ 2 Baths ⋅ Ocean View SubDv. ⋅ 34242 Zip Code
WELCOME TO THE SIDE OF SIESTA KEY YOU NEVER WANT TO LEAVE. Glistening Heron Lagoon stretches peacefully behind this beautifully restored and renovated income producing single family home, while just beyond, the Gulf of Mexico makes its presence known through salty breezes and the sound of waves in the distance. Surrounded by lush tropical greenery on a deep Siesta Key lot, this is an exceptional combination of island lifestyle, 5 Star vacation home with income potential and long term land value. Tax records reflect four bedrooms, with the fourth currently enjoyed as an office, plus two full baths. Single story, built to enhance the open, airy feeling inside, while the home's connection to the outdoors keeps the peaceful lagoon and tropical setting at the center of everyday life. Following the 2024 storms, the home was extensively renovated, fully permitted and improved creating a fresh and beautifully finished property. The new kitchen and baths, gleaming tile floors and light filled interiors are perfectly suited to relaxed island living. Your private pool and spa are surrounded by tropical greenery with the peaceful waters of Heron Lagoon beyond. Spend afternoons by the pool and enjoy spectacular sunset colors. The deep lot provides a wonderful sense of space and privacy, while the substantial brick paver driveway offers abundant parking for owners and guests, an increasingly valuable feature on Siesta Key and an important advantage for a successful vacation rental. For the investor or second home buyer, the opportunity becomes even more compelling. This highly sought after vacation rental generates approximately $114,000 in annual gross rental revenue despite being only self managed by an out of state owner. It offers an established income stream with the flexibility to enjoy the property yourself, creating the possibility of owning a Siesta Key getaway that can also work for you when you are away. Prior to the extensive restoration and improvements that followed, the property received an appraisal with an opinion of value of $1,300,000 as of September 2024. Since that time, substantial additional work and improvements were completed. What cannot be duplicated is the setting and the land. A deep single family homesite on Siesta Key overlooking Heron Lagoon, surrounded by tropical greenery with the Gulf just beyond offers tremendous possibilities. Continue its successful vacation rental use, make it your island getaway, enjoy it as a full time residence, or hold an increasingly scarce piece of Siesta Key real estate for the future. The property offers approximately 1,625 square feet of living area, four bedrooms per tax records, two full baths, a garage, private pool and spa, dock, covered outdoor living space, and extensive brick paver parking. Glistening lagoon views. Gulf breezes and the sound of the waves. Tropical privacy. Deep lot. Generous parking. Proven rental income. Extensive post storm restoration and renovation. Long term Siesta Key land value. This is more than a successful vacation rental. It is a beautiful single family home, an island escape, an income producing property and an opportunity to own a special piece of Siesta Key. Property documentation reflects a 2017 roof, 2020 plumbing re pipe, 2021 water heater and 200 amp electrical service. Flood insurance is 8,734.00 per year, Homeowners insurance is 7,788 per year and there is no HOA. Come for the opportunity. Stay because you may never want to leave.

8302 Midnight Pass Road, Sarasota
7233 Pine Needle Road, Sarasota
$1,175,000
Sanderling Club SubDv. ⋅ 34242 Zip Code
An exceptional opportunity to create a custom residence in the Sanderling Club, one of Siesta Key’s most distinctive gated communities. This 30,676 sq. ft. homesite features direct lagoon access, offering the ability to kayak, paddleboard and fish right from the property. Aerial photography showcases the lot’s proximity to the Gulf of Mexico along with Sanderling’s lush landscaping and canopy-lined roads. Within the 24-hour guard-gated community, property owners have access to a collection of private amenities, including the Club’s Gulf beach, marina on the Intracoastal Waterway, Gulfside tennis and pickleball courts, and the iconic Paul Rudolph-designed clubhouse. With more than 30,000 sq. ft. of land, direct access to the lagoon and a location near the Gulf, the property offers an outstanding setting for designing and building a home tailored to your vision. Enjoy time on the water, days along the Gulf and everything this established Siesta Key community offers to it's members.

7233 Pine Needle Road, Sarasota
1130 W Peppertree Lane Unit 118, Sarasota
$670,000
2 Beds ⋅ 2 Baths ⋅ Peppertree Bay SubDv. ⋅ 34242 Zip Code
Live the Siesta Key lifestyle! This beautifully maintained 2-bedroom, 2-bath condo offers the perfect combination of island living, rental potential, and resort-style amenities. Ideally situated in the desirable Gulf-side community of Peppertree, this second-floor residence is just a short stroll from the tennis and pickleball courts, heated pools, and Siesta Key’s private-access beach. From the moment you arrive, you’ll appreciate the peaceful setting and tranquil views overlooking one of Peppertree’s picturesque ponds. The condo has been thoughtfully updated with all new impact windows, renovated kitchen and bathrooms, and updated flooring, creating a comfortable and inviting beach retreat. The spacious primary bedroom easily accommodates a king-size bed and features a walk-in closet. The home is offered turnkey furnished, making it ready to enjoy immediately or continue as a seasonal rental. It has consistently generated rental income during peak season, while also providing the flexibility to enjoy it personally during the off-season. Additional features include a full-size washer and dryer, newer A/C installed in 2019, a private storage unit conveniently located just outside the back patio, and a dedicated parking space. Peppertree is truly a destination within Siesta Key, offering direct Gulf-to-Bay access, a private fishing pier, tennis and pickleball courts, two heated pools, two clubhouses, BBQ grills throughout the community, beach chairs, car wash areas, and on-site management with a rental program. High and dry with no storm damage, this exceptional condo offers the opportunity to own your own piece of paradise on world-famous Siesta Key. Whether you’re looking for a personal beach getaway, an investment property, or the best of both, this inviting Peppertree residence is ready to welcome you home.

1130 W Peppertree Lane Unit 118, Sarasota
6265 Midnight Pass Road Unit 102, Sarasota
$675,000
2 Beds ⋅ 2 Baths ⋅ Excelsior Beach To Bay SubDv. ⋅ 34242 Zip Code
Virtually Staged. Experience the world renowned beaches of Siesta Key in this rarely available first floor luxury condominium steps away from your private deeded beach access. Conveniently located to Siesta Key’s south bridge, accessing the mainland, shopping in the village and access to nearby restaurants and stores is a breeze. Take the free public transport available to Siesta Village or head to Turtle Beach. Arrive home to a tastefully decorated unit with peaceful courtyard lake views. Entertaining and sharing a meal is an event with this updated chef’s kitchen. The enclosed lanai invites you for a cup of coffee, a book or contemplation. The primary suite features wood flooring, a true retreat like en-suite bath and upscale built-ins for the closet. Have peace of mind with impact windows and a new HVAC system installed 2025. There is plenty to do without going to the beach. Two heated pools, hot tubs, pickleball, tennis, fitness, fishing dock, library, beachside restrooms and more.

6265 Midnight Pass Road Unit 102, Sarasota
9226 Midnight Pass Road Unit 3B, Sarasota
$650,000
2 Beds ⋅ 2 Baths ⋅ Castaway Cove SubDv. ⋅ 34242 Zip Code
It's time to SIMPLIFY! Sun. Sand. Surf. Fantastic Opportunity and sure to impress! The last unit in this community sold for 800,000. Welcome to this completely renovated residence at Castaway Cove, a boutique waterfront condominium community tucked away on the quiet south end of Siesta Key, just a short walk to Turtle Beach. This second-floor unit offers a rare coastal vantage point with sweeping views of Blind Pass Lagoon, the Intracoastal Waterway, and the Gulf of Mexico, delivering a rarely found three-water perspective. Morning light reflects across the lagoon, afternoons might feature manatees or dolphins, and evenings are reserved for unforgettable sunsets over the Gulf. Dock space is potentially available for boating enthusiasts, and the calm lagoon waters provide ideal conditions for kayaking and paddleboarding from Castaway’s private launch toward the newly-opened Midnight Pass. The residence has been remodeled wall to wall and floor to ceiling since 2020, with thoughtful attention to both design and infrastructure. The open floor plan blends the kitchen, dining, and living areas seamlessly, allowing water views to take center stage from nearly every angle. Porcelain tile flooring runs throughout the entire unit, creating a clean, cohesive look that complements the seaside setting. The kitchen features shaker-style Providence White cabinetry with glass-front display cabinets and interior lighting, a pantry with pull-out shelving, Pompeii Quartz countertops, a Glazzio tile backsplash, and updated appliances including refrigerator, range, dishwasher, built-in microwave, washer, dryer, and HVAC system. The primary suite, perched above Blind Pass, is a serene retreat with crown molding, solid core doors, and custom closet systems with mirrored panels. The ensuite bath offers dual vanities topped with Pompeii Quartz, a walk-in shower with glass enclosure, tiled bench, multiple body jets, subway tile walls, and subtle motion-sensor lighting. The guest suite, with views of the ICW, features a barn door entry and a bath with cast-iron tub and quartz-topped vanity. A screened lanai extends the living space outdoors with porcelain tile flooring, a tongue-and-groove ceiling, new screens and railings, and tranquil water views that invite morning coffee or evening relaxation. Additional features include recessed lighting throughout, ceiling fans, a woven dining area chandelier, sheer and room-darkening solar shades, Schlage door lock, Ring doorbell, and Nest thermostat. Castaway Cove is a low-density community of just eight residences offering ample parking, professional management, and exceptionally low association fees. Recent community improvements include a new seawall, refreshed landscaping, updated exterior lighting and irrigation system, and a freshly painted building. The two-story structure is NOT subject to a Milestone Inspection.

9226 Midnight Pass Road Unit 3B, Sarasota
Start Your Search

How much is your home worth?

Get instant property value now!