Myakka City Homes with Pond Frontage

Myakka City Homes with Pond Frontage

Welcome to Myakka City, Florida – a hidden gem nestled in the heart of Manatee County. This charming, rural community is known for its breathtaking natural beauty, wide-open spaces, and a lifestyle that embraces the tranquility of country living while remaining conveniently close to urban amenities. With its lush landscapes, vibrant wildlife, and a warm, welcoming atmosphere, Myakka City offers an idyllic setting for those seeking a peaceful retreat.

One of the standout features of homes in Myakka City is the stunning pond frontage that many properties boast. Imagine waking up to the gentle sounds of nature, sipping your morning coffee while gazing out over serene waters, and enjoying the picturesque views that change with the seasons. Homes with pond frontage provide a unique opportunity to connect with the outdoors, whether it’s fishing, kayaking, or simply enjoying the tranquility that comes with living by the water.

The community is rich in recreational activities, with nearby parks and nature preserves offering hiking trails, birdwatching, and opportunities for horseback riding. The charm of Myakka City is complemented by its close-knit community feel, where neighbors become friends and local events bring everyone together.

For those looking to escape the hustle and bustle of city life without sacrificing convenience, Myakka City is a perfect choice. With easy access to nearby cities like Sarasota and Bradenton, you can enjoy the best of both worlds – a serene lifestyle surrounded by nature, with the excitement of urban living just a short drive away. Explore the beauty of Myakka City and discover your dream home with pond frontage today!

Newest Myakka City Homes with Pond Frontage

Myakka City
$1,000,000
34251 Zip Code
Bring the Horses and Cows! Two dream land parcels in Myakka City just inside the Manatee county line being sold together. This 83+ ACRE Farm features a deep well of approx 400 ft. for water supply in the middle of the property driven by WINDMILL power. This beautifully maintained farm is FULLY fenced and all set up for cattle with two large fenced off Hay fields, a corral and chute for loading cattle. Hay can be used for farm use to feed cattle, horses or other animals. The owner typical bales up many bales of hay multiple times per year. The two parcels are mostly level and cleared with 2 good size flag ponds for cattle to drink or wade in. The current owning family has hunted on the land as well. The wooded section in the southeast corner is lovely and has a path for trucks or ATV's through the middle of a gorgeous canopy of large oaks and palms. You will find deer, hog, turkeys, and other wildlife on the property from time to time. It is peaceful the moment you drive up. At night, you can see so many stars. This is 83+ acres of well cared for and wonderful land has many potential uses. Listing Realtor is related to owners. The property must be toured to be appreciated completely. Please allow for enough time to see the whole property, it typically takes one hour + to see the full two parcels and ask any questions you may have. The pictures can not even begin to express the experience of walking this land.

Myakka City
28401 104th Dr E, Myakka City
$1,175,000
3 Beds ⋅ 4 Baths ⋅ Magnolia Hill Subdivision SubDv. ⋅ 34251 Zip Code
FIRST TIME ON THE MARKET! Set on 5 peaceful acres in Myakka City, with nearly 3,000-square-feet, this custom built home offers the rare combination of privacy, usable acreage, substantial workshop and storage space, along with the freedom of country living—all with no HOA's or CDD fees. This 3 bedroom, 3.5 bath home also includes a dedicated office along with a spacious floor plan with the primary suite conveniently located on the main level. A soaring vaulted ceiling in the living room creates an open, airy feel, while the wood-burning stove adds warmth and character. Fresh interior paint (2026), brand-new carpet (2026), metal roof (2020) along with newer plank vinyl flooring, appliances and HVAC system. The home has undergone an inspection with careful attention given to maintenance and needed items so this home is ready for its next owner. Step outside and the possibilities are endless. Mature oak trees frame the property, while a peaceful pond and inviting country front porch create the perfect backdrop for quiet mornings and relaxed evenings. With five acres to enjoy, there is room for animals, gardening, recreational vehicles, equipment and the outdoor lifestyle you've been looking for. For the hobbyist, boater, RV owner or anyone needing extra workspace and storage, the property delivers a 30' x 36' powered workshop providing approximately 1,080 square feet of dedicated space, complemented with a 16' x 36' covered outdoor kitchen and entertaining area. A separate 16' x 30' covered lean-to would accommodate a high-tower boat, RV or additional equipment, all while still having a 10' x 10' lean-to for whatever your heart desires. The attached two-car garage and storage breezeway provide even more storage, indoor parking and overall flexibility. While the setting feels wonderfully removed from the hustle and bustle, you don't have to sacrifice convenience. Downtown Lakewood Ranch and Downtown Sarasota are both approximately 30 minutes away, while I-75 is about a 20-minute drive, making it easy to enjoy all the shopping, dining, entertainment and recreation found throughout the surrounding area. For frequent travelers, Sarasota-Bradenton International Airport (SRQ) and Tampa International Airport (TPA) provide convenient options for regional and international travel. The property is also located within Manatee County's top rated school district. Whether your vision includes horses and country living, a workshop for your projects or business, space for your boat and RV, or just simply five private acres where you can spread out and enjoy Florida's rural beauty, this property offers something increasingly hard to find in our area: space, versatility and freedom—all in one place.

28401 104th Dr E, Myakka City
40916 11th Avenue East, Myakka City
$2,250,000
5 Beds ⋅ 4 Baths ⋅ Winding Creek SubDv. ⋅ 34251 Zip Code
Melissa’s Hope is a custom barndominium-style home built by Homes by Laura, Inc. and a 2026 Parade of Homes Winner. Designed to blend everyday comfort, equestrian functionality, and long-term flexibility, the main level features an open great room, kitchen, walk-in pantry, office, primary suite, two guest bedrooms, and an expansive porch. A drive-through breezeway, tack and feed room, and three stalls create a seamless connection between the home and outdoor living. Upstairs, a private two-bedroom apartment with a kitchen, living room, bathroom, and generous closet space offers flexibility for guests, extended family, or multigenerational living. Located on 5.86 acres in the wonderful, peaceful community of Winding Creek. Within the community, Winding Trails Ranch often hosts barrel races and other events. Far enough away from the crowded city life and only an hour drive down state road 64 to Anna Maria Island Beach. This lifestyle is one you will quickly fall in love with.

40916 11th Avenue East, Myakka City
1210 408th Court E, Myakka City
$1,090,000
4 Beds ⋅ 3 Baths ⋅ Winding Creek SubDv. ⋅ 34251 Zip Code
Luxury, privacy, & nearly 6 FENCED ACRES come together in one extraordinary custom-built Mark Cahill estate in Myakka City. Behind the PRIVATE CODED MOTORIZED ENTRY GATE, you'll discover the freedom, space, & lifestyle today's buyers are searching for. Based on current land & construction costs, recreating a comparable estate like this today could approach $2 MILLION, making this an exceptional opportunity to own a luxury country property without the wait, uncertainty, or rising costs of new construction. Inside, soaring ceilings, 8-FOOT DOORS, crown molding with accent lighting, a dramatic double tray ceiling, elegant chandeliers, & ALL TILE FLOORING create an impressive yet welcoming atmosphere. Built-in shelving anchors the living room, while an aquarium window frames peaceful views of the pool from the main living areas. The flexible floor plan offers 4 BEDROOMS, 3 BATHS, formal living & dining rooms, a dedicated office, & an oversized kitchen with breakfast bar & island. Step outside to your own private retreat featuring a SALTWATER PebbleTec pool with SOLAR HEAT, a RESISTANCE SWIM SYSTEM for year-round exercise, winter safety cover, cool deck, RETRACTABLE MOTORIZED AWNING, sunshade, pool bath access, outdoor shower, & a fenced dog run—all designed for entertaining, relaxing, & enjoying Florida's outdoor lifestyle. Need room for hobbies, horses, recreational vehicles, or a home-based business? The 900 SQ FT WORKSHOP is a standout feature, offering WATER, POWER, approximately half under AIR CONDITIONING, pass-through access, & attached COVERED PARKING for boats, trailers, or equipment. The home also includes an oversized 3-CAR GARAGE. Built with durability, efficiency, & peace of mind in mind, this home features HURRICANE-IMPACT WINDOWS & GARAGE DOORS, ICYNENE INSULATION, an OWNED 9.5 kW SOLAR SYSTEM, GENERAC GENERATOR with buried 250-GALLON PROPANE TANK, a security system with sensors on all doors & windows, & a BRAND-NEW (2026) $30,000 WELL SYSTEM with sulfur filtration & chlorinated pipes. The barrel tile roof adds timeless curb appeal, & the property has experienced no flooding or hurricane damage. Winding Creek offers a peaceful country setting with a private community park, lakefront picnic area, riding opportunities, community events, & LOW HOA FEES of just $800 per year. Nearby boating, parks, nature preserves, bow hunting, & the local motorsports facility provide endless opportunities for outdoor recreation. Be sure to explore the Matterport 3D Tour & review the complete Features Sheet to discover the many additional upgrades & amenities this remarkable estate has to offer. Schedule your private showing today & discover why this extraordinary property represents an exceptional opportunity to own a luxury estate that's difficult to replicate at today's construction costs.

1210 408th Court E, Myakka City
28154 Gopher Hill Road, Myakka City
$2,395,000
5 Beds ⋅ 4 Baths ⋅ Pomello Park SubDv. ⋅ 34251 Zip Code
NEW PRICE! AN EXTRAORDINARY OPPORTUNITY TO OWN A PRIVATE 5+ ACRE LUXURY ESTATE! OVER 5 ACRES. THREE BUILDINGS. ONE EXTRAORDINARY ESTATE. Discover a rare opportunity to enjoy luxury living, exceptional privacy, and incredible versatility on more than five acres in Myakka City—with no HOA. This gated estate is fully fenced, featuring white vinyl privacy fencing along three sides and attractive open-style vinyl and steel fencing across the front. A picturesque spring-fed pond enhances the property's natural beauty and peaceful setting. The impressive main residence offers a chef's kitchen, private home theater, two dedicated offices, impact-rated windows and doors, and a luxurious primary suite designed for relaxation. Offered partially furnished, this home is ready for your next chapter. Step outside into your own private resort, complete with a sparkling pool, spa, outdoor kitchen, fire features, and expansive entertaining areas. Whether hosting unforgettable gatherings or enjoying a quiet evening under the stars, this property delivers an exceptional Florida lifestyle. What truly sets this estate apart are TWO ADDITIONAL BUILDINGS offering remarkable flexibility. A separate, fully air-conditioned building of approximately 3,000 square feet features a private office, full bathroom with shower, two additional rooms, and an expansive garage occupying nearly half the building. Whether you're a car enthusiast, collector, entrepreneur, or simply seeking extra space for hobbies and personal pursuits, this remarkable building provides exceptional versatility. The third building, a separate three-stall garage, offers even more possibilities for a creative studio, hobby space, private lounge, or additional storage. Imagine having room for your vehicles, hobbies, work, and recreation—all within your own private estate. Three buildings. Five-plus acres. Exceptional privacy. Endless possibilities. Experience the freedom to live life on your terms. Schedule your private tour and discover everything this extraordinary property has to offer.

28154 Gopher Hill Road, Myakka City
3035 Logue Road, Myakka City
$499,850
34251 Zip Code
NEW PRICE = Unbeatable Value! Here's your chance to own nearly 10 acres of secluded, partially cleared land featuring breathtaking views, two ponds, and endless possibilities for your dream home, family compound, mini farm, equestrian estate, recreational retreat, or buy & hold for future appreciation. No HOA and no deed restrictions. With electric, water, septic, and high-speed internet already in place, much of the groundwork has been completed. Whether you're ready to build immediately or enjoy the property while planning your future residence, this unique offering provides flexibility that is increasingly difficult to find. A 1,500sf metal garage/workshop with three 10' overhead bay doors was built in 2011, offering ample space for vehicles, boats, trailers, farm equipment, recreational vehicles, or hobbies. A new septic tank was installed in 2023, and approximately 400sf of the building has been converted into air-conditioned flex space complete with a full bathroom and washer/dryer hookups. The flex space is fully insulated, including the ceiling, and additional storage is still available above. Buyer to verify permitting, allowable use, square footage and suitability for intended use. Approximately 1,100 SF of workshop/warehouse space remains. Two fenced and cross-fenced pastures ideal for livestock or horses! While portions of the rear acreage may hold water during periods of heavy seasonal rainfall, this property is flood zone x (no flood insurance required). According to the previous owner, the larger pond was excavated to approximately 32 feet deep to promote drainage, stormwater management, and healthy fish habitat. This spring-fed pond is stocked with bass and bluegill, while the second pond serves as a livestock pond. Wildlife enthusiasts will appreciate frequent sightings of deer, wild turkeys, monarch butterflies, and a variety of native bird species, including migrating bluebirds. Outdoor recreation opportunities abound, with Duette Preserve located less than one mile away and accessible via Logue Road. Spanning more than 21,000 acres, Duette Preserve is the largest preserve in Manatee County and offers extensive riding trails, wildlife viewing, hunting opportunities, and access to the headwaters of the Manatee River. Enjoy the peace and privacy of country living while remaining within convenient reach of Lakewood Ranch, Sarasota, shopping, dining, golf, and entertainment. May be available for lease purchase depending on the terms, ask for details.

3035 Logue Road, Myakka City
11149 Price Lane, Myakka City
$2,089,500
3 Beds ⋅ 4 Baths ⋅ Neighborhood Subdivision SubDv. ⋅ 34251 Zip Code
Under Construction. Timeless architectural design with luxurious, livable spaces. From the moment you enter, the grand foyer and elegant great room set the tone for this home. The open kitchen is a chef’s dream with high-end appliances, quartz countertops, and a large center island. A spacious owner's suite includes dual walk-in closets and a spa-inspired bath. Three bedrooms, a bonus room, and a study provide flexible living options. The expansive outdoor living area includes a covered lanai and pool—ideal for enjoying Florida’s year-round sunshine. Every detail is thoughtfully designed and meticulously crafted, delivering comfort, style, and exceptional quality. Soleta is a private, luxury golf community nestled in the heart of Myakka City, Florida, offering an elevated lifestyle rooted in Old Florida charm. Spanning over 530 acres of preserved natural landscape—including moss-draped oaks, palmetto prairies, freshwater marshes, and two miles of the scenic Myakka River—Soleta is designed for those seeking tranquility, recreation, and refined living. At Soleta, every day feels like a getaway — and membership is your key to it all. To maintain the exclusive lifestyle and unparalleled amenities that define this community, all residents are required to become members of the Soleta Golf & Country Club. Both social and full golf memberships are available, ensuring you enjoy the full spectrum of everything Soleta has to offer. Live where luxury and leisure come together —

11149 Price Lane, Myakka City
11157 Price Lane, Myakka City
$2,175,500
3 Beds ⋅ 3 Baths ⋅ Soleta SubDv. ⋅ 34251 Zip Code
Pre-Construction. To be built. Step into modern luxury with this home by John Cannon Homes, a custom-designed masterpiece offering refined contemporary living. This single-story residence features expansive open-concept spaces with soaring ceilings, floor-to-ceiling glass, and seamless indoor-outdoor transitions. The gourmet kitchen boasts designer appliances, custom cabinetry, and a spacious island—perfect for entertaining. The owner's suite is a private retreat with a spa-like bath, oversized walk-in closets, and a serene view of the lanai. With three additional en-suite bedrooms, a study, bonus room, and an outdoor living area complete with a pool and summer kitchen, the Soleta is crafted for comfort, style, and everyday elegance. Situated in Soleta a private, luxury golf community nestled in the heart of Myakka City, Florida, offering an elevated lifestyle rooted in Old Florida charm. Spanning over 530 acres of preserved natural landscape—including moss-draped oaks, palmetto prairies, freshwater marshes, and two miles of the scenic Myakka River—Soleta is designed for those seeking tranquility, recreation, and refined living. Nestled among scenic fairways and sparkling lakes, Soleta combines elegant architecture with resort-style amenities designed for those who crave the exceptional. Residents enjoy access to a world-class golf course, a stunning clubhouse, fine dining, a state-of-the-art fitness center, tennis and pickleball courts, spa services, and vibrant year-round social events. At Soleta, every day feels like a getaway — and membership is your key to it all. To maintain the exclusive lifestyle and unparalleled amenities that define this community, all residents are required to become members of the Soleta Golf & Country Club. Both social and full golf memberships are available, ensuring you enjoy the full spectrum of everything Soleta has to offer. Live where luxury and leisure come together —

11157 Price Lane, Myakka City
Start Your Search